Julie Amero: Persecution of the Innocent
Posted by Karoli in Education, News February 18th, 2007
Comments are now closed on this post. Thank you all for your support, blog posts, and the heart for justice. I’m working on a roundup of everyone’s comments and a final tally of the donation to Julie Amero’s Defense Fund as a result of your participation.
Julie Amero is the seventh grade substitute teacher in Connecticut who is facing 40 years in prison after pornographic popup ads came up on her computer screen during a class in 2004.
When I first read about this story, Amero was on trial. I assumed that the defense would show that the ads were clearly the result of a spyware/adware infection and she would be acquitted. My shock went deep (along with just about everyone with an ounce of understanding about how malware works) when she was convicted of multiple counts of exposing children to pornography. My outrage is just as keen, knowing that she was not permitted to introduce evidence of a malware attack because the defense failed to do so at the pretrial phase.
Amero and her husband are broke. A sad result of these specious accusations and mockery of a trial: Amero was 4 months pregnant when she was arrested, and lost her baby as a result of the stress. A miscarriage of justice, truly.
Amero has established a defense fund to try and pay for her appeal, which is accessible via her blog. Click the paypal link and give to her fund. If you do Whether you contribute or not, leave a comment on this post and I will add $1.00 for every comment posted in the next 48 hours. I’ve already donated $20 — but would be glad to donate ten times that amount with your help. Please blog about it, too.
If this conviction stands as it is, it will cast a pall on the use of technology in education but more fundamentally, will punish the wrong person — the one who deserves the jail time and firing is the lazy network administrator who couldn’t be bothered to keep the network locked down.
(Hat tip to Liz Ditz for the links to the blog and defense fund. Also for the link to the blog State v. Amero - A Miscarriage of Justice)
UPDATE: I’ve posted links to additional information here. This morning, Steve Bass at PCWorld posted links to two EXCELLENT articles here and here, addressing the duty of the prosecutor to use qualified experts. Had the prosecutor done that, there would have been no case.
Technorati Tags: Julie Amero, criminal law, malware, spyware
Sphere: Related Content
…living life in 19/7 time 
[...] to the Julie Amero Defense fund and leave a comment here. I will add $1 for each commenter who donates to her defense fund that’s posted in the next [...]
I also emailed 23 bloggers I know — mostly edubloggers — asking them to join me in supporting Julie Amero’s legal defense fund.
You can count all my responses as one.
Mamacita wrote a heartfelt response on her blog, SchiessWeekly:
Please Help If You Can; This Could Happen To Any Of US, And Has
I feel really sorry for Julie and her family. What a nightmare. I donated via paypal a few minutes ago…..definitely worth it if it frees her from this mess and points future prosecution at those who write and distribute spyware instead of the victims.
Since this case is on to the appellate stage, both the trial court prosecutor and appellate prosecutor need to let themselves be educated by the forensic technoligist, so this case can be dismissed and all charges dropped. Thank you for giving this some light.
[...] I need you to do something. Go visit Karoli and lend support. She’s making donations today for a substitute teacher’s defense fund and I’d [...]
This Case has in Turn Appalled annoyed worried and Saddened me,
If this is Justice American im glad i dont Live there,
It Bothers me that Few of the Spammers/malware/virus/trojan writers are Ever prosecuted and Yet Julie has Been the Victim of a Techno Phobic Witch hunt the like of which i have never seen before and hope not to ever see again….
Oh good Lord. There is just all kind of wrong going on with this case. What kind of idiot was her defense attorney if he/she didn’t include the findings of a forensic technologist?
The idiocy of the courts never ceases to amaze. Here’s to hoping she’s found innocent.
I’m rooting for Julie and our justice system to right itself. Thank you for providing a way to help.
I am amazed at how the school administration, the police department, a prosecutor, a judge, an entire jury, the local newspaper, and a host of others were so blinded by outrage at the notion of exposing young kids to sexually explicit images in a classroom, that they forgot to, or intentionally did not investigate the all circumstances of the case.
And now, Julie Amero’s career and life are shattered by people that don’t know all the facts.
The good news is that some of the top people in the computer security realm have offered their expertise and will testify on Julie Amero’s behalf at her appeal. We can only hope that good sense and justice will prevail at the appeal.
Free Julie Amero!
I can not even fathom how she got in trouble for this to begin with! It’s ridiculous. I hope that she is found innocent this time around. I wish her all the best in the future!
What a great judicial system we have that will put away a young teacher for 40 years for something that popped up on her screen, but yet, drug dealers in and near the schools get a slap on the wrist. I am going to submit this story to Reader’s Digest’s “That’s Outrageous” I am sure they would love to hear about this.
-S.
The more I thought about this the angrier I get. There are teachers that sexually abuse students, and online predators that get less time when caught than she is getting.
-S.
what a horrible miscarriage of justice. I’m off to make a donation.
I was the computer teacher in a Catholic school for a year (and thereby the default tech support person), and porn pop-ups kept happening on the 2nd grade teacher’s computers. She was a NUN. I managed to fix it. I cannot imagine why people are prosecuting this.
Our justice system (and government) MUST educate themselves on current technology! This is just so wrong-headed, I can’t believe it.
You all are wonderful! Thanks for visiting! The more I read about this case, the more frustrated I am that she is in this mess.
Tell your friends — A comment and/or pingback puts $1 more into her defense fund — no obligation required.
It might be because I live in Australia but I must admit to not knowing anything about this case. With no reading at all, even I, a stay home Mum, am quite capable of figuring out that no one should be subjected to this kind of treatment for a god damned POP UP.
I have been caught unawares by pornographic pop up’s while surfing the web with my 2 boys numerous times. I am not computer savvy and have had to trust my computer tech to install whatever we needed to keep our net safe for the kids. I cannot comprehend how they can be blaming Julie?
I’m going to go read as much info as I can find on this right now. I cannot credit that it’s even possible to get 40 years in prison for a pop-up. It’s heartbreaking and just shows what a totally anal and f’d up world this is becoming.
My prayers go out to Julie and her family. May Justice actually be carried out and set her free.
[...] wonderful blogger is offering to donate $1 for each comment or trackback to Julie Amero’s defense. You can read Julie’s blog for donation information and other [...]
[...] justice. Thanks to all of you who have commented so far to raise money for her defense fund here. There is no obligation on your part beyond leaving a comment or a trackback to my post. For [...]
This is the kind of thing you think would be a Saturday Night Live sketch, not something that really happened! I will post this link on my blog and advise as many others as I can. I don’t know why we’re shocked though. Remember Senator Stevens “the Internet is a series of tubes” speech? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f99PcP0aFNE&mode=related&search=
The ridiculousness is obvious to anyone who spends time online and invisible to the rest of America. I just wonder how those prosecutors do their legal research if they don’t go online!
[...] wonderful blogger is offering to donate $1 for each comment or trackback to Julie Amero’s defense. You can read Julie’s blog for donation information and other info. [...]
Thanks again for pointing out this case in flickr.
I do not know much about the american justice system, ’cause I never have been to america (and sorry - don’t take it personaly: at the moment I feel like it’s not the paper worth laws are written on), but first I thought this is a bad hoax and “no, this can’t be true” ’cause as a german I would expect a court sentence about two years on probation. If at all - but not more.
Anyway - I’m very sorry for her and her family and I hope the case went her way.
Of course this is “worse” of [sorry for my limited english] or better “cries” after donating some money to support her.
Joerg Lingnau,
Network- and Systemadmin
Essen, Germany
Thanks for doing this. This case makes me so sad.
This is such an outrage! Having been the victim of a porn loop myself when I accidentally hit yes instead of no on a virus scan warning box I have experienced first hand how out of control a computer can get in seconds. Short of turning it off there sometimes is no way out. To assume that a substitute teacher - not savvy in all things computer - should have known what to do - just dumb.
Then the great system of justice has let her down also.
Our so-called “Great” society has let her down as well.
[...] your comment or track back to my post by 2PM PDT 2/20/2007 and I will add a dollar to Julie Amero’s defense [...]
This is just so bloody stupid.
As a teacher (and as a human), I appreciate what you’re doing.
Thank you, Karoli, for being so ardent in your support of Julie Amero. Why we take the innocent and victimize them and let so much else happen why turning a blind eye to them infuriates me. Of course, I’m in support of teachers and all that emcompasses, but what’s the real story? Who were they trying to catch doing something?
So many more questions. You are a real blessing to know, my dear. Your example speaks volumes.
why can’t julie sue the school district for negligence, since they did not update their firewalls?
truly a miscarriage of justice - those jurors should be ashamed of themselves.
I don’t understand how something like this could go this far? Her defence attorney couldn’t get this thrown out of court? Is the physical evidence that hard to disput?Does someone benefit politically from this?
Good lord this is insane. thank you so much for you generous offer to match comments with $$. Things like that really work to raise attention as well as money.
came here via mocha momma. this is horrendous, and i’m glad to have heard about it, so i can try to help. thanks for doing this.
I just put in $10.00. I will try and blog about it tomorrow too.
That poor woman! Those people are terrible.
How unfortunate. Our justice system is a crock.
Many thanks for giving us the forum to respond to this outrage.
Oftentimes when we hear about blatant miscarriages of justice all we
can do is wring our hands and feel sorry for the person.
Bless you for providing a venue for concrete assistance.
I just learned of this, and am shocked deeply. Thank you for doing this.
Thanks for providing this forum to help.
Outrageous. As an American expat living in Saudi Arabia - I would expect something like this to happen here - most definitely NOT in my home country! This is what the slippery slope must look like.
I would like to support this campaign. It is an appalling miscarriage of justice.
What a horrible mess!
What a BRILLIANT idea — thank you for pulling all this information together, including the fund raising possibilities.
This is truly frightening.
i hope justice takes off the blindfold and sees Julie for the innocent victim she truly is!
This is completely bogus! I feel for that poor woman and her family & especially the innocent baby that was lost!
[...] all are awesome! Since I posted on Sunday, there are just over 50 comments and trackbacks to my post, and Scoutj has opened up the opportunity for anyone who donates to the Julie Amero Defense Fund to [...]
I sincerely hope justice happens in this case - what a sad case of our system failing someone.
Thank you for doing this.
That is some messed up stuff. And an incredible misuse of the justice system.
This story makes me very angry at the legal system. I don’t understand how this can happen. This is not how we hear about it in high school government class. Thanks you for doing this.
i found you through scout’s blog.
i blogged about it myself today and made a donation to their fund.
I found you through Scoutj’s blog. I’ve posted about this on my blog and have made a donation to Julie’s fund. I can’t believe that they would prosecute someone for something like that. What is this world coming too. I’m just glad there are people like you can Scoutj who are bring this to our attention.
[...] drumsnwhistles.com/2007/02/18/julie-amero… [...]
the powerfully stupid…
No, I’m not talking about Dumbya this time. I don’t know why I hadn’t heard about this before, but I just followed a link from Jeneane’s post dealing with education and found out about Julie Amero, the seventh grade substitute……