Squelching the editor

by Karoli on April 6, 2009 · 15 comments

I’ve started this post in my head a zillion times but it never makes it to the blog because my evil twin, the Rigid Editor, always deletes it before I hit the “publish” button.

I hate The Editor, yet have to acknowledge her hold on me. She shuts me up if I get creative by reminding me that my strength is expository writing, the how-tos and rants, dry explanatory posts that read like the business letters I’ve written for 30+ years. Creativity, she reminds, is the domain of the young and the trained.

She reminds that I’ve never had an original thought, that all plots and characters have been seen and written by other, better, funnier people before leaving me with the final admonition that my sense of humor was never my strongest suit.

See why I hate her? She’s every negative defeating thought I’ve ever had, bundled in a business suit holding a stack of check stubs reminding me that her talent has paid the bills for a long, long, time and I’d do well to remember that.

Getting rid of The Editor is a scary thing but I can’t help but think that if I did, I’d be a heckuva lot more interesting and so would this blog. Much of what I’ve been doing has been a concerted effort to put The Editor in a more balanced place, but she crawls out anyway like a whack-a-mole, waiting to strike me with lightning before I drop anything other than the conventional and the expected out on the public stream.

Worse yet, she doesn’t limit herself to my writing. She crawls in my camera, my sketchbook and my journals, always with that whiny, self-defeating conventional song. The one that says it’s just not right to do anything different because someone’s done it anyway and done it better already. Or the more insidious “you never could draw your way out of a paper bag…” This is the same voice that turned me back from studying music in college, claiming I was probably talented but not gifted and besides, classical musicians rarely made enough to get by.

Her incessant whisper: “Don’t give up your day job.” Yeah…

Well, Ms. Editor, about that day job? See, I’ve been without one for about 4 months now and there is no posse at my front door begging me to sign on somewhere else. Experience matters less than paper these days — paper that holds no guarantee the bearer can put a coherent sentence together, think critically, or have the benefit of experience when making judgment calls. Some can, some can’t. But in the world of corporate hiring, that paper is the golden ticket. The Editor is simply a bonus that rides on the expressway rolling through HR, nice but not necessary.

This is my declaration of independence from the shackles of She Who Defeats. No more. I’m putting her in a box and letting her out to write business letters and how-to posts when needed. She is otherwise banished from my camera, journals and sketchbooks, twitter stream and most importantly, my head.

Hold me to that, would you?

  • http://mickelehsoap.blogspot.com Michael_Markman

    The most liberating thing I've read since… I can't be bothered to remember. (oops that got through uncensored.)

  • ursulas

    Wow! I admire your writing talent. Had no idea that The Editor was haunting you!

    I know The Editor too. It's funny how she creeps in and takes over. Years ago, I wrote poetry and fictional stories. Then I became a grant writer and worked in city and county planning. My writing talent was spent on dry, explanatory technical pieces.

    I let The Editor cut my creative tongue out.

    Don't let it happen to you, Karoli! You remain such a breath of fresh air, force of nature and all that good stuff!

  • http://www.drumsnwhistles.com/ Karoli

    ursulas and mickeleh,

    Thank you for the encouragement! I am hoping that by putting this in writing and in public, I'll hold her at bay.

  • kmilyun

    Oh this could prove to very entertaining and interesting emmm . … LOL

    Side note: I always thought of you as talented, creative, and enlightening.

    I call my editor the little %$*& in my brain – it can be found running around on the squirrel there.

  • http://www.drumsnwhistles.com/ Karoli

    Awww, thanks for the nice words. But there are days where I just bite back what I really want to write, thinking yeah, it'll either confuse everyone who reads this blog or else it's just too…not me. The thing is, when I read my posts that I like best, they're rants. I actually don't rant that much…it just seems like it here.

  • bbluesman

    Get rid of the editor yes! Please what ever you do -DON”T SEND HER HERE! Kthbai…

  • http://www.katemclaughlinpoetry.com Kate McLaughlin

    My inner editor can be a real intruder, and I don't even do that for a living. Don't know how you manage to stifle her at all!

  • http://lifebehindthecurve.com EmmieJ

    What a great post. I've found this to be the hardest part of blogging (which I've been doing for a much shorter period of time than you). I have ideas in my head but my Editor kicks in and tells me all the reasons why I shouldn't write that or how no one will care and I just never get around to getting down what I wanted to say.

    I, for one, find your writing to be thought-provoking and easy to read. I look forward to reading your unedited self even more in the future.

  • finnigh

    All of life is derivative. We are the sum of what we know, yet we are each blessed with out own unique take on things.

    Karoli, I think your Editor is simply akin to the proverbial 'cranky old librarian', who shushes people as they make exciting discoveries in the course of their learning.

    Go ahead, copy the masters. How do you think *they* learned?
    Because YOU are different, I guarantee your work product will be different, in some small way. Or perhaps a big way. Who knows?

    Our end seldom comes at a convenient time. I think it would be a hell of a dismal thing to lie on one's deathbed enumerating the different ways of saying “Gee, I wish I would have tried that…”.

    Yea, we're all going to have a few regrets when we pass, but there's no need to add to the pile while we still have our choices.

    Take care,
    John

  • http://www.drumsnwhistles.com/ Karoli

    Thanks, John. I agree with you — it would be really too bad to be facing one's last day on Earth and taking an account of all the risks one didn't take. Still, I've got to say, facing down that voice and keeping it quiet is one of the biggest challenges I've had.

  • http://www.drumsnwhistles.com/ Karoli

    Thank you, Kate, that's really nice of you to say. I'm working on that unedited self thing every day. Seems to be easier with the camera and the sketch pad than the written word, but I think that's because what I write really represents who I am…and it's not always what I want everyone to see..

  • http://www.drumsnwhistles.com/ Karoli

    she's on her way to you. :)

  • bbluesman

    nooooo so don't have the welcome sign on for her. Puts on Nixon mask to
    scare her off…

  • http://thoughtbythought.net Tre

    You got it.
    Idea: not that anyone has any more time for anything else..but what about some kind of touch base group….ya know? see how we are doing silencing her and squelching her up.
    Not sure what that would look like.
    Possibilities endless….800 phone call once a quarter? once a month? once a week?
    a voice chat?
    ck in by dm's or tweets?
    a tweet discussion for all to see #innercritc but based on the filtering discovered of late perhaps no?
    think with me….but i'm here to offer a safe space to bare all…goodness knows I wouldn't be where I am mentally if i hadn't learned to squelch her hourly.
    Ever the goal she's ousted for good. :)
    (In case this sounds way more confident than it ought, I have to still squelch her hourly)
    :) kay…think about it. maybe you know others. Maybe you have something like this already in place?
    Neat idea….and I may go ahead and pursue it somehow….
    Hugs for the admittance….means tons.

  • http://thoughtbythought.net Tre

    You got it.
    Idea: not that anyone has any more time for anything else..but what about some kind of touch base group….ya know? see how we are doing silencing her and squelching her up.
    Not sure what that would look like.
    Possibilities endless….800 phone call once a quarter? once a month? once a week?
    a voice chat?
    ck in by dm's or tweets?
    a tweet discussion for all to see #innercritc but based on the filtering discovered of late perhaps no?
    think with me….but i'm here to offer a safe space to bare all…goodness knows I wouldn't be where I am mentally if i hadn't learned to squelch her hourly.
    Ever the goal she's ousted for good. :)
    (In case this sounds way more confident than it ought, I have to still squelch her hourly)
    :) kay…think about it. maybe you know others. Maybe you have something like this already in place?
    Neat idea….and I may go ahead and pursue it somehow….
    Hugs for the admittance….means tons.

Previous post:

Next post: