No Democracy in Wisconsin today. #WIunion

by Karoli on March 9, 2011 · 5 comments

Late Update: Jessica Arp with the local CBS affiliate reports that the Senate has just passed the bill by a margin of 18-1 — with only moderate Republican Dale Schultz voting no, in absence of the Democrats who had fled the state in order to block budget quorum.

via Wisconsin Conference Committee Passes New, Stripped-Down Anti-Union Bill | TPMDC.

So, Gov. Scott Walker made his move this afternoon and bifurcated the budget bill. Republicans stripped out all collective bargaining provisions from the budget bill in a joint committee this afternoon, then brought only the collective bargaining piece to the Senate floor where it passed with no Democrats present, 18-1.

Please, conservative commenters, be aware that I’m unlikely to tolerate any whining about how the healthcare bill was “rammed down” your itty bitty gullets after seeing this, so don’t even bother with that. Filibusters in the US Senate are broken with compromise. In Wisconsin, not so much.

It’s not democracy. What is it, exactly?

Here’s an answer from Keith Olbermann on what it is: Suicide of the Republican Party

Still having never learned to be calm, retract their claws, and sit around and act rationally in a situation that calls for panic, Wisconsin’s Republicans and their Corporate Puppeteers tonight guaranteed themselves an unprecedented and disastrous recall next January.

More over, they also guaranteed themselves that any cloak of stealth under which they have operated in their attacks on teachers, firefighters, policemen, unions, and the settled law of collective bargaining, has been stripped away. If you pass a supposedly urgent “budget repair” bill with key budget components cut from it, you forfeit the fiction that you are doing anything remedial, anything essential, anything except a naked power grab on behalf of corporations who will get the money stolen from organized labor – civic or private.

And further, when you accomplish all this by parliamentary trick – after your national party has spent two years and more decrying Congressional reconciliation – when you deny the minority the right to participate in the outcome whether by compromise or protest, you cut through the cacophony of political-speak in this country and you transmit your sneering indifference towards democracy to ordinary citizens who do not normally pay attention.

  • Mmfmarga

    yeah! Olbermann!

  • http://www.copywritingdean.com/ Stephen Dean

    I think what happened was democracy.

    On Twitter you asked if I thought filibusters were undemocratic. Yes, they are. That doesn’t mean they’re bad. They’re good. I like them. And had this issue been on something more liberty oriented rather than public unions, I would have been cheering on the 14.

    The reason I like filibusters even though they’re undemocratic, is because democracy is not the highest value.

    The constitution often contains bits that protect us from democracy. The congressional rules often have rules that protect us from democracy. This is all good. I support this, because majority rule is often not a good thing.

    So, I disagree with the title of your post. There was democracy.

    And on another point entirely, unless they broke the rules (I have no idea), then they played by the same rules that allowed the filibuster. Sounds legit to me.

  • http://twitter.com/BACFA Bread and Circuses

    I think you may get the @CryBabyPrize today. We won! Suck it.

  • http://www.drumsnwhistles.com/ Karoli

    but do you know what you won? No, you really don’t. No one does, because it is not yet published. So you might just find yourself sucking it.

    Love ya, don’t ever change.

  • Anonymous

    Anyone that thinks that what is going on in WI is ‘democracy’ is ignorant. Laws are being broken by the Legislature and the Governor. People’s Rights are being taken away and contracts are being breached—with no discussion allowed. It’s pure dictatorship, and that is not democracy.

Previous post:

Next post: